For Sale 609 Pittsburgh, Cape May, NJ, 08204

Rare Opportunity to own a large 125 x 125 lot in Cape May with an opportunity to Build your own Custom Home on the Island. Located within blocks of the Cape May Harbor and Marina District and neighbooring up against Preserved Land. Walk to several shops, The South Jersey and Cape May Marina\'s and Restaurants like the nostalgic Lobster House, Mayer\'s, C-View, and Lucky Bones in addition to several others. Uniquely the Adjacent lot is also available to purchase. Seller is working with a land development engineer and the state of New Jersey for clear interpretations of building on one of the last vacant lots in the District. Come visit and walk this Unique tranquil lot.

Where luxury meets location—this home checks all the boxes. Designed to capture the charm and timeless appeal of historic Cape May, this stunning 6-bedroom, 3.5-bath coastal retreat offers all the modern comforts in one of the most coveted locations in town. With classic cedar shake-style siding, rich engineered wood floors throughout, and sun-filled interiors, this home blends Old Cape May elegance with resort-style living. Ideally located just steps from the beach on the highly desirable beach block, you’re perfectly positioned to enjoy everything Cape May has to offer. Take a short stroll to the sand, bike into town for coffee and shopping, or enjoy family-friendly movies under the stars behind Convention Hall. Cape May is one of America’s oldest seaside resort towns, and this home allows you to experience it at its best. Outdoors, a private fenced backyard features a beautifully designed patio area and in-ground pool with water feature—ideal for summer gatherings, afternoon cocktails, or simply unwinding in your own sanctuary. Multiple levels of open-air porches offer ocean breezes and a peek of the Atlantic from the second-floor deck off the master suite. Inside, the spacious yet cozy layout was designed for both entertaining and relaxation. The first floor features an open-concept floor plan with seamless flow from the living room to the dining area and kitchen. A double-sided gas fireplace adds warmth and charm, perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach. The kitchen is a chef’s dream—elegant and functional, with plenty of space for multiple cooks to prepare meals and treats, whether it’s Sunday dinner or summer snacks whipped up by “NoNa.” The second-floor master suite spans the entire rear of the home and includes a private deck with ocean view, a luxurious en suite bathroom, and plenty of space to retreat in peace. Two oversized guest bedrooms on the same floor share a spacious hall bath, ideal for family or guests. The third floor includes three additional generous-sized bedrooms, providing flexibility for sleeping arrangements, home office space, or creative use. Additional highlights include: • Private outdoor shower with hot & cold water • New awnings for shade and curb appeal • Off-street parking for added convenience • Long-standing, strong rental history • Turnkey opportunity as a second home, vacation rental, combination of, or full-time residence Whether you’re seeking an investment with proven returns or your dream home by the sea, this property offers exceptional value in one of Cape May’s most exclusive neighborhoods. The lifestyle you’ve dreamed of is here—just a 1/2 block from the beach.

Beautiful Cape May Home on Oversized Lot – Endless Possibilities Welcome to this lovely home located on a 75x125 ft. lot full of potential in the heart of Cape May! This rare home features an attached legal two bedroom apartment which offers a unique blend of modern comfort, historic charm, and unbeatable flexibility—perfect for year-round living, summer getaways, or income-producing investment. The main House features 3 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, thoughtfully laid out for both privacy and flow. At its heart is a stunning oversized gourmet kitchen, complete with a center island, double ovens, double sink, and an additional bar sink—ideal for entertaining or effortless family living. The kitchen opens into a light-filled dining and family room, creating a warm and welcoming open-concept space perfect for gatherings. Off of the family room is a nice sized laundry room and 1/2 bath. Two bedrooms and 1.5 baths are located on the first floor, while the entire second level is dedicated to a private master suite, featuring hardwood floors, a spacious walk-in closet, and a spa-inspired bath with a separate walk-in shower and a walk-in soaking tub—your own personal retreat. A sun-filled all-seasons room just off the family room leads to a rear deck overlooking the expansive backyard. The newer vinyl-fencing offers a private retreat. The yard offers ample room for a pool and includes an enclosed outdoor shower and a detached heated/cooled cottage—ideal as a future pool cabana, studio, or perfect for your home office or man cave/she shed. The attached 2-bedroom, 1-bath apartment has its own private entrance, separate meters and utilities, and offers washer/dryer, stove, and dishwasher hookups. While the unit hasn\'t been used recently as income producing it\'s fully legal and offers strong potential for rental income or guest use. Additional highlights include: • Newer roof • Newer central heating and air conditioning • All-new Andersen windows throughout • Large front porch • Generous off-street parking Located just minutes from Cape May’s beaches, restaurants, and historic downtown, this property is a rare find. With its oversized lot, versatile layout, and income potential, it’s the kind of home that doesn’t come along often. Don’t miss your chance to make this special Cape May property yours—schedule your private showing today!